Whenever we see a case involving service by publication, that's a hugeeeeee red flag for a judgment buyer. Here's why we won't buy a judgment involving service by publication, and why a judgment that relied on it, frankly, stinks. If we hear a judgment was served by publication, the first thing I think is "I don't want that case."
Our case study is Cunningham v. Montes, 883 F.3d 688 (7th Cir. 2018), and it's a fascinating one. Lots of mistakes on both sides here, and some definite takeaways about what not to do in a lawsuit.
Back in 2016, Craig Cunningham sued Michael Montes and several of Montes's businesses in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin. Cunningham said they called his cell phone 176 times using an autodialer. That's illegal under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (the "TCPA"), and it's a law plenty of companies routinely violate.
Montes owned two houses: one in San Juan Capistrano, California, and a farm in Somerset, Wisconsin. In November 2016, a deputy from the St. Croix County sheriff's office tried to serve Montes at the Wisconsin house. Nobody came to the door. So the deputy did something most process servers don't bother to do: he called Montes on the phone.
Side note: calling the defendant first is pretty dumb if you're trying to serve someone. It's like Darth Vader force-choking Admiral Ozzel in The Empire Strikes Back for coming out of lightspeed too close to the Hoth system, because now "the Rebels are alerted to our presence." Except here, it's the defendant who's alerted to our presence, because the sheriff basically told him, "PROCESS SERVER RIGHT HERE!" And that's bad. We want to catch them by surprise, not say "Hey, I'm trying to serve you, please make it easy for me!" Very few sophisticated defendants are going to make it that easy.
You can guess where this is going. Montes refused to give the deputy his address, claimed the Somerset house was a rental property, and told the deputy that Cunningham would have to "hunt him down." While we're on the topic of pretty stupid things to say, that's definitely up there, especially when you're talking to a law enforcement officer who's trying to find you. It went straight into the deputy's report.
That one visit was the only attempt at service. Cunningham then went to the judge ex parte, meaning without Montes there to respond, and asked for permission to serve by publication. He didn't tell the judge about Montes's California house. The judge granted it. Cunningham published notice in periodicals that circulate only in the Midwest, from March 9 to March 23, 2017. In other words: stick it in some newspaper that nobody reads, in small font, on an obscure page almost nobody will ever look at. There's a 0.0001% chance the defendant ever sees that.
Service by publication isn't automatic. The court has to grant a special order, and you have to make a real showing first. In Wisconsin, the statute (Wis. Stat. § 801.11(1)) only allows it when "reasonable diligence" hasn't gotten the papers into the defendant's hands.
That means you have to diligently attempt service at ALL of the defendant's known addresses, and make a reasonable inquiry to find out what those addresses are. It's not enough to say "I don't know where he is." You have to go down several rabbit holes in good faith: skip-tracing, vehicle registrations with the DMV, property records, voter registrations, and even asking the local postmaster whether the defendant's mailing address is current or there's a forwarding address on file. The court wants to see that you really did your due diligence before it authorizes service in a newspaper no one reads.
When Montes didn't answer the complaint, the court entered his default, and Cunningham moved for a default judgment. Montes found out about the lawsuit from a defendant in another one of Cunningham's cases. Shortly before the default judgment hearing, he got a lawyer and moved to set aside the default and fight the case on the merits.
If I were the judge reviewing a motion like that, I'd probably grant it, as long as it was promptly filed and the defendant had a reasonable excuse for not responding on time.
However, this was not a normal case, and this particular federal district judge did not go for it. He was a strict judge who didn't tolerate defendants he felt were playing games and dodging service. At a June 20, 2017 hearing, he found Montes hadn't shown good cause to set aside the default. Then, in a July 18, 2017 order, he wrote that "Montes has rather persistently sought to evade service in both California and Wisconsin," found that Montes really lived in Wisconsin, and entered a judgment for $176,450. He even froze the Wells Fargo accounts of Montes's businesses until Cunningham collected. Case closed. Or so it seemed.
Here's a fun detail from a footnote in that order: Montes admitted he was in Wisconsin from March 22 to April 5, 2017, so he was actually in the state during the last days the notice ran.
That's a lot of money, and Montes wasn't going to pay it. He appealed to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. He filed an affidavit saying his principal residence was the California house, and listing every date he and his wife were in Wisconsin in 2016 and the first half of 2017. If that affidavit was true, he was in California when the deputy showed up in Wisconsin. And Cunningham conceded he knew Montes's California address, but never tried to serve him there.
At oral argument, Cunningham explained he skipped California because the house was listed online for rent by the week, so he concluded Montes didn't live there. (Later, he also pointed out that in an earlier case in Tennessee, he'd sent the lawsuit to the California house by certified mail in March 2016, and it came back unclaimed.)
The Seventh Circuit vacated the judgment and sent the case back. Judge Frank Easterbrook, a very esteemed and well-respected judge, wrote the opinion for the panel:
The judge did not elaborate on his statement that "Montes has rather persistently sought to evade service in both California and Wisconsin"; indeed, the judge did not relate what Montes has done to evade service in either state. True, no one opened the door when a deputy sheriff arrived in Wisconsin with a summons, but being at a different home in a different state is not a form of evading service. True, Montes did not provide his address when the deputy sheriff called, but anyone can claim over a phone to be a public official with a legitimate need for information; few people will provide personal details to strangers in response to cold calls. And there is no evidence that Montes has evaded service in California, because Cunningham concedes that he has not tried to serve Montes there.
And on the rental listing:
At oral argument Cunningham told us that he decided not to serve Montes in California because listings on the Internet show that the California house is available for rent by the week. Cunningham concluded that Montes does not live in California at all. That's not a good inference. Many people who divide their time between two houses try to cover part of the cost by renting out the place they are not using at the time. Businesses offer time-share services to homeowners, and the advent of Airbnb enables owners to handle these arrangements on their own. It would not be sound to treat as unoccupied (by the owner) any house available to rent by the day or week. And the district judge did not so treat Montes's house in California. Neither, however, did the judge explain how the statutory requirement of "reasonable diligence" is satisfied by a plaintiff who did not try to serve the defendant at one of the defendant's known addresses.
The court also pointed out that Wisconsin requires more than a single visit from a process server, and requires a plaintiff who knows, or could easily learn, that the defendant has multiple addresses to try to serve him at each one. Unless new evidence showed the publication statute was satisfied, the default had to be vacated and the case decided on the merits.
Cunningham got one more shot. In May 2018, the district judge held an evidentiary hearing where both Cunningham and Montes testified.
It did not go well for Montes's credibility. He expressly admitted telling the deputy that Cunningham would have to hunt him down. The judge found his testimony "evasive and not credible." His sworn declaration had said nobody lived at the Somerset house, but at the hearing he testified that his wife and son had lived there since 2011, except for most of 2016 and early 2017. Cunningham even had bank records showing Montes in Wisconsin on dates his declaration left out.
And Montes still won. The judge agreed that one attempt at the Somerset house was enough, since Montes basically told the deputy he'd never be found there. But Cunningham knew about the California house and never tried to serve Montes there, not even once. The certified mail from the Tennessee case didn't count. Wisconsin law doesn't allow service by certified mail, and a single piece of unclaimed mail doesn't prove personal service would have been pointless. As the judge put it in his May 25, 2018 order, "Reasonable diligence would call for Cunningham to attempt personal service at the California property at least once. He did not."
The court ruled the service was deficient and the default judgment wasn't warranted. A $176,450 judgment, gone. The case went back to square one, to be decided on the merits.
Think about that. The defendant admitted to "hunt me down," the judge called his testimony evasive and not credible, and the plaintiff still lost the judgment, because he skipped one address.
Takeaway #1: Service by publication sucks. It's the last resort, and you don't want to do it. Make every attempt to personally serve the defendant. Sometimes that means getting creative, like the time we got a debtor served in a camper van after he dodged service for six months.
Takeaway #2: Attempt service at ALL known addresses. Don't be lazy, or you could end up with a vacated judgment. One skipped address cost this plaintiff $176,450, even with a defendant the judge didn't believe.
Takeaway #3: If you're the defendant, don't play games. It's a really stupid idea to say anything implying you're hiding, dodging service, or not cooperating with the legal process. It's best to just accept service, call a lawyer, and deal with things head-on in court. Hiding from a process server is just not a winning strategy, and it could lead to a judgment against you.
This case is exactly why we won't buy a judgment that was served by publication. Picture a judgment buyer who paid the seller for that $176,450 judgment, then watched the courts wipe it out. That money is gone, with no way to get it back. For more on what we look for in a default judgment, see How Much Will Someone Pay for My Judgment?
If your judgment is over $25,000 and the debtor was personally served, send it to us or call (484) 312-3300 for a no obligation cash offer.
Final Verdict Solutions buys civil money judgments over $25,000. Get a no-obligation cash offer. If you accept, you get paid and collecting the judgment becomes our job, not yours.
2001 Market Street, Suite 2500
Philadelphia, PA 19103