Short answer: A judgment buyer pays a portion of the balance, never the full amount, and the exact offer depends on how likely the judgment is to be collected. The biggest factors are whether the debtor has assets or income you can reach, whether it's a default judgment or a litigated one, which state the judgment is in, how old it is, and how much is owed. Two judgments for the same amount can get very different offers. The best way to find out what yours is worth is to have a buyer review it.
Because the buyer is paying you cash today for a right to collect that might take years, cost thousands in enforcement, and in some cases never pay off at all. The buyer takes on all of that time, cost, and risk. In the judgment buying world, the discount reflects the tremendous risk a judgment buyer takes on, and their desire to obtain a return for their investment.
1. The debtor's assets and income. This matters more than anything else. A debtor who owns a home with equity, has money in the bank, earns steady wages, or runs an active business is far more collectible than one with nothing in their name.
2. Whether it's a default judgment. This matters tremendously. Default judgments are worth significantly less to a judgment buyer than litigated judgments, and we scrutinize them more closely than anything else. See "Default judgments: what we look for" below.
3. Whether anyone has already tried to collect. If someone has already examined the debtor, or done any enforcement really, that significantly lowers the value. They already gave away the element of surprise. In The Empire Strikes Back, Darth Vader executes Admiral Ozzel for coming out of lightspeed too close to the Hoth system, because now "the Rebels are alerted to our presence." Same thing here. Once a debtor is alerted to our presence and knows what's coming, that torpedoes the chances of a successful sneak attack bank levy with no warning.
It also puts the debtor on alert to hide their assets. A debtor who knows collection is coming won't likely stay lazy and sloppy. They're far more likely to get an attorney, who will advise them on how to avoid collection, hide their assets, or otherwise put them out of creditors' reach.
And if a debtor's exam (in California, an ORAP) was already done, unless the attorney who conducted it was experienced in judgment collection, there's a high likelihood the results weren't great.
The only thing that's a strong idea to do right away is record a judgment lien (in California, that's called an abstract of judgment). Laying down your liens is incredibly smart, but there are many ways to screw it up on the technical or procedural side. So get a good attorney, or just call Final Verdict Solutions and we'll take a look at buying your judgment.
4. Whether the debtor is a person or a business. Businesses can have accounts, receivables, and equipment to go after, but a business can also close its doors. Individuals can have wages and real estate, but some move or hide assets.
For a business debtor, it tanks the value of the judgment if the LLC or corporation is out of business, defunct, closed down, or dissolved with the Secretary of State.
Another red flag is when the debtor starts doing business under a new or similar-sounding name that's actually a newly formed entity. That's a real headache, because going after the new company requires a finding of alter ego or successor liability. That means a ton of discovery, motion practice, depositions, subpoenas and everything else to prove it in court. It's not enough to say "they're the same guys doing the same thing." You have to prove it in court.
It's also a pain if the debtor's name is spelled wrong in the judgment, or the judgment names them by an alias or the wrong name. Fixing it means filing a motion to amend or correct the debtor's name, or in California, an affidavit of identity. It's really annoying, and it's extra time and expense before collection can even start. But it's really important to clean this up. We need the exact name on the judgment that the debtor holds title to real estate under, so we can create a valid judgment lien against the real estate. And we need the correct name so the bank can locate the right account or accounts when a bank levy is served.
5. The state. Enforcement rules vary a lot. For example, Texas doesn't allow wage garnishment for ordinary debts and has a strong homestead protection, while California lets creditors garnish wages and record liens on real estate. The same judgment can be worth more in one state than another.
Florida is one of the hardest states to enforce a judgment in. Debtors there get a lot of protection. The homestead exemption has no dollar cap, so a debtor's home is off the table completely, no matter how much it's worth. A debtor who is the head of a family can often shield their wages from garnishment. And property a married couple owns together as tenants by the entirety is protected from a judgment against just one spouse. A Florida judgment can be worth a lot less than the same judgment in a state with stronger collection tools.
6. How old the judgment is. Judgments eventually expire unless they're renewed. A judgment with many years of life left is worth more than one about to run out. Interest keeps adding to the balance in many states, but a bigger balance only matters if the debtor can pay it.
7. The amount. For a judgment buyer, smaller judgments are often not worth getting out of bed for. Larger judgments present the opportunity to collect more money, but with that comes the chance that the debtor will lawyer up and fight harder. That's why Final Verdict Solutions has a minimum amount of $25,000.
That's not a knock on smaller judgments. There's a saying: "There are no small cases, only small lawyers." What that means is that every case that goes to court is important. If it was important enough for someone to take the time to go to court over, it's probably very important to that person, even if it's a small claims case. At Final Verdict Solutions, we just believe the best use of our time is going after the larger judgments.
8. Other debts and liens. If tax liens, mortgages, or other creditors are ahead of you, there may be less left for your judgment.
9. Bankruptcy risk. A debtor who files for bankruptcy can wipe out or delay many judgments. A recent or likely bankruptcy lowers the offer.
10. Whether the judgment is final. If the debtor can still appeal or is trying to vacate the judgment, most buyers will wait until that's settled.
If the debtor never responded and the court entered a default judgment, we scrutinize the proof of service, because that's the first thing the debtor's attorney will attack. Debtors often claim "I was never served." Even when service was proper, a debtor can file a motion to vacate or set aside the default if they move quickly, have a reasonable explanation for not responding, and have a meritorious defense. Courts prefer to decide cases on the merits, so judges take these motions seriously. For a buyer, a granted motion to vacate is the worst possible outcome: the judgment is gone, and so is the money they gave the seller for it, with no way to get it back. That's why any weakness in the proof of service on a default judgment lowers the offer, or ends the deal.

Weaknesses we look for in a proof of service include:
Service that looks outright deficient under the state's law is a deal killer. For example, "served the debtor's brother" is not good service if the debtor doesn't live with his brother.
We don't buy default judgments where the debtor was served by publication. Service by publication has very strict requirements, it's easy to attack, and it rarely gives the debtor actual notice, because almost nobody reads legal notices in the newspaper.
Service by certified mail is highly questionable too. Even where a state's law allows it, debtors routinely claim "I didn't sign that," "I never got it," or "that person wasn't authorized to sign for me."
The same goes for service by posting, also called "nail and mail," where the papers are posted on the debtor's door and then mailed. Debtors always claim they never received them.
If a process server has a history of fraudulent service, often called "sewer service," that's a major problem, and we won't take a case where we suspect it happened. We prefer service by the sheriff, a U.S. Marshal in a federal case, or a registered process server (called a certified process server in Florida, Texas and some other states). Registered process servers have to register with the county, so courts view them as far more credible than someone serving papers with no credentials.
We also want to see that the debtor got notice of entry of the judgment by a means we can verify. The strongest is a mailing from the clerk of court. Judges believe the clerk actually mailed it, because clerks are public officials with no dog in the fight, they're required by law to send it, and they have no reason to lie. That mailing is noted on the docket, which is strong evidence. Other strong proof is a mailing to the debtor's actual address by certified mail, return receipt requested, by Priority Mail with tracking and proof of delivery, or by a commercial carrier like UPS or FedEx. An email to the debtor is also good, especially if they replied, because a reply shows they got it.
Something really strong is when the debtor has acknowledged the judgment is valid by making voluntary payments or trying to settle it. It's hard for a debtor to tell a judge they never knew about a judgment they have been paying on, or making active settlement overtures in an attempt to put the entire matter to bed for a discounted payoff.
It's also strong when the debtor acknowledges in writing that they received the judgment or know about it, or leaves a voicemail for the plaintiff's attorney asking to discuss the case a few days after notice of entry of the judgment is mailed out. That's exactly what happened in our San Diego fraudulent transfer case: the debtor called the creditor's lawyer about the "stuff you sent to me in the mail," and that voicemail later proved he knew about the judgment.
A judgment is also worth more if the debtor already filed a motion to vacate or set it aside and the court denied it, as long as that denial is final and can no longer be appealed, or the court of appeals affirmed it. The debtor already took their shot and lost. We had exactly that in a California case where the debtor's motion to vacate was denied by the trial court and never appealed.
Really, anything that shows the debtor clearly knew about the judgment helps, especially when they chose to fight the collection instead of the judgment itself. A few years ago we had a debtor who filed a claim of exemption against a bank levy, but never moved to vacate the actual judgment. Months later, after the judge denied her claim of exemption and she had no other way to stop the enforcement, she finally filed a motion to vacate. The court found it wasn't promptly filed, because she had appeared at multiple hearings over several months without ever once filing a motion to vacate. She should have done that immediately. Not surprisingly, her motion was denied, and the court was not impressed with her conduct.
We want to hold debtors accountable, but we can't ignore it when their due process rights were clearly violated. We'd love to hammer them, but doing that when we know the debtor's rights were violated in some way wouldn't be right. It would also jam us up legally, because the debtor's attorney will inevitably hit us with a motion to vacate, raise those exact points, and argue to the judge that their client was denied fundamental due process rights. So we need a clean fact pattern and a record showing every one of the debtor's due process protections was followed.
Problems with the debtor
Problems with service and notice
Problems with the case or its history
Send a copy of the judgment to a buyer and ask for a written offer. At Final Verdict Solutions, we research the judgment and the debtor, then give you a no obligation cash offer. You never pay us any fees, and you're free to say no.
Is a bigger judgment always worth more?
No. A $40,000 judgment against a homeowner with steady income is worth more than a $400,000 judgment against someone with nothing.
Does interest increase what a buyer will pay?
Only if the debtor can actually pay the higher balance.
Should I try collecting first and sell later?
No. We do not recommend attempting to collect on your own without the help of a qualified attorney who actually does judgment collection. Once you've examined the debtor or started enforcing, you've given away the element of surprise, and that significantly lowers what a buyer will pay. If you're thinking about selling, do it before you start collecting. The one exception is recording a judgment lien, which is smart to do right away, with help from someone experienced.
Can I get offers from more than one buyer?
Yes. Just make sure every offer you compare is an actual purchase, not a deal where someone collects for a percentage of the net recovery.
If you have a judgment of $25,000 or more, send it to us or call (484) 312-3300. We'll research it and give you a no obligation cash offer.
Final Verdict Solutions buys civil money judgments over $25,000. Get a no-obligation cash offer. If you accept, you get paid and collecting the judgment becomes our job, not yours.
2001 Market Street, Suite 2500
Philadelphia, PA 19103