She Fought the Garnishment Instead of the Judgment. Big Mistake.

November 17, 2026

This case study is one of those cases where we all think "what were they thinking here?" Put this one in the category of "Oops, that seems like a dumb move, dude!"

The judgment debtor was on the hook for a large judgment entered in Santa Clara County, California. By the time it was renewed, it had grown to $115,000. She was a doctor working for a hospital, making good money. According to her employer, she was grossing over $24,000 a month. So the judgment creditor did what creditors do against debtors with multi-six figure salaries: go after the paycheck. First came a bank levy on the account her paychecks were deposited into, then a wage garnishment served on her employer. Easy enough, right?

Until of course, the debtor files a claim of exemption. That's one of the really annoying things debtors can do – they can come in and argue their wages shouldn't be garnished due to their financial circumstances. California law is designed to protect struggling debtors who really, truly are broke and need every dollar to feed their families and pay the rent, not high-earning doctors. On the form for the claim of exemption, the debtor gets to list their income and expenses. Of course, debtors often try to inflate their expenses, throwing things in there that aren't exactly necessities of life.

‍

Round one: the bank levy

In 2022, the creditor levied her bank account and caught about $30,000. She filed a claim of exemption, showed up to three hearings, and filed her bank statements to prove the money in the account came from her paychecks. It did, so the court treated it like garnished wages, and the creditor got a portion of it.

Notice something? She came to court three times to fight over the money. Not once did she say the judgment itself was invalid.

‍

Round two: the wage garnishment

Then came the wage garnishment. A couple of months later, she filed another claim of exemption, asking that none of her wages be garnished. Her own paperwork said she grossed about $18,000 a month. The creditor filed an opposition with a statement from her employer showing she actually grossed nearly $25,000 a month.

The judge wasn't impressed. Her wages looked understated, and she didn't have the evidence to back up her expenses. The claim of exemption was DENIED, and her wages were ordered garnished at 25% of her disposable earnings.

Ouch.

‍

The motion to vacate: too little, too late

Right around the time she filed that second claim of exemption, the debtor finally did what she should've done right away: filed a motion to set aside the default judgment. She argued that she was never served with the underlying summons and complaint, and that there was no connection between the address where service occurred and her. The proof of service said the papers were left with a receptionist at an office in Santa Clara back in 2012. She said she'd never lived or worked in Santa Clara and had never heard of the person who supposedly took the papers. Her lawyer argued the judgment was void, so she could attack it at any time.

Unfortunately for her, the judge didn't buy it. The court denied the motion for two separate reasons:

1. It was too late. The judgment was valid on its face, so the court applied the deadline in California Code of Civil Procedure section 473.5: relief has to be sought no later than two years after the default judgment is entered. This default judgment was entered in 2012. She waited over ten years.

2. She waived it. She filed a claim of exemption, attended three hearings, and was the subject of two court orders, and never once challenged the validity of the judgment. By fighting the collection instead of the judgment, she gave up her chance to set it aside.

Instead of filing that motion right away, she elected to file claims of exemption and challenge the actual collection proceedings. She should have said "please vacate this entire judgment."

This did not go well for the debtor.

‍

F around, and find out

This was a slimeball debtor who was clearly f***ing around, and found out. She was a doctor grossing over $24,000 a month, telling the court none of her wages should be garnished. She understated her own income. She came to court three times to fight over the money and never said a word about not being served. Then, once the creditor started getting paid, she suddenly claimed she never knew about the lawsuit. The judge saw right through it.

‍

Why this matters if you're selling a judgment

A default judgment against a debtor who fought the collection instead of the judgment is worth more to a judgment buyer. It shows the debtor knew about the judgment, and here the court has already shut the door on a motion to vacate. For more on what drives the value of a judgment, see How Much Will Someone Pay for My Judgment?

If your judgment is over $25,000, send it to us or call (484) 312-3300 for a no obligation cash offer.

Holding a judgment over $25,000?

Final Verdict Solutions buys civil money judgments over $25,000. Get a no-obligation cash offer. If you accept, you get paid and collecting the judgment becomes our job, not yours.

Get a Cash Offer
or call (484) 312-3300

Sell your judgment for cash

Did you know over 80% of court judgments go uncollected according to the American Bar Association? Final Verdict Solutions is here to remedy that problem.
Get Started

2001 Market Street, Suite 2500
Philadelphia, PA 19103

Get directions on Google Maps